California Is Expanding the Right To Delete. Is Your Email Marketing Compliant?
- Email Marketing & Automation

Short on Time? Jump to our SB 923 and CCPA Email Marketing Guide for a quick overview of who needs to comply and what changes are needed.
A healthy, curated email list is arguably your most valuable marketing asset. But having direct access to someone’s inbox also comes with a responsibility to handle their personal data carefully.
California’s Senate Bill 923 (SB 923) was recently signed into law, expanding consumers’ ability to request the deletion of their personal information under the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA). The CCPA 2027 updates take effect January 1, 2027.
Before we get into the nitty-gritty of these changes, not every business needs to comply with CCPA privacy regulation (more on this later).
For those that do, it means taking a closer look at where contact details come from, creating a process to handle deletion requests, and preventing records from reappearing after they’ve been removed.
This new legislation also reinforces a best-practice for email marketing: gradually and organically building your email list, giving you greater control and visibility.
First—Does CCPA Even Apply to Your Business?
The CCPA does not automatically apply to every company sending marketing emails to California residents.
The law generally covers for-profit entities that do business in California and meet at least one of the following three criteria:
| Qualification | Current Threshold |
| Annual gross revenue | $26.625 million or more, based on the inflation-adjusted threshold effective January 1, 2025 |
| Consumer data volume | Buy, sell, or share personal information belonging to 100,000 or more California residents or households annually |
| Revenue from selling or sharing personal information | Derive 50% or more of annual revenue from selling or sharing California residents’ personal information |
These thresholds reflect current California Privacy Protection Agency guidance. The revenue threshold is adjusted for inflation every other year, so check the latest figures when evaluating your company’s obligations.
Nonprofits and government agencies generally fall outside the CCPA’s definition of a covered business, although separate requirements may apply depending on the organization’s activities and relationships.
For additional guidance, consult the California Privacy Protection Agency’s CCPA FAQs or speak with legal counsel about your specific circumstances.

What Is SB 923, and What’s Changing in 2027?
The CCPA already gave eligible consumers the right to request the deletion of their personal information. SB 923 addresses a gap in how that right applies to information companies obtain from other sources.
The legislation makes 2 key changes:
1. The Right to Delete Covers Third-Party Data
Previously, the CCPA’s deletion provision focused on personal information a business collected directly from a consumer. That left a gap when the information was obtained from an outside source.
Starting January 1, 2027, the right to request deletion will cover personal information a covered business has collected from or about a consumer, regardless of the information’s source (subject to applicable exceptions).
For email marketers, that can include contact records obtained through purchased prospect lists or information added to existing records by third-party data providers.
When a valid deletion request comes in, a process is needed for locating and removing covered information across all systems where it’s stored.
Deleting a contact from your email platform is no longer the end of the process. If another system or vendor can reintroduce that record, you are now required to find a way to prevent that from happening.
Unsubscribing and Deleting Data Are Not the Same Thing
An unsubscribe request stops marketing emails. Under CCPA email rules, a deletion request requires a broader review of how personal information is held.
Your process should distinguish between the two and route each request appropriately.
2. Certain Online-Only Businesses Must Offer an Online Request Method
SB 923 also changes how some consumers can submit privacy requests.
Previously, those operating exclusively online with a direct relationship with the consumer could meet the applicable submission-method requirement by providing an email address.
Starting January 1, 2027, those businesses must provide both an email address and an online method, such as a web form or portal, for submitting applicable right to delete requests.
If your company falls into this category, review your website’s privacy policy and contact options. Consumers should be able to find where to submit requests without difficulty.

What Are the Risks of CCPA Noncompliance?
CCPA compliance is a legal obligation for covered businesses, and violations can carry significant financial consequences.
SB 923 expands the information that must be addressed when responding to deletion requests, making it important to have a reliable process in place before the changes take effect on January 1, 2027.
CCPA Fines and Penalties
The California Privacy Protection Agency (CPPA) and the California Attorney General can take enforcement action against those who violate the CCPA.
As of 2025, the CCPA’s inflation-adjusted administrative fine limits are:
| Type of Violation | Maximum Administrative Fine |
| Standard violation | $2,663 per violation |
| Intentional violation | $7,988 per violation |
| Violation involving a consumer under 16 when the business has actual knowledge of their age | $7,988 per violation |
Source: California Privacy Protection Agency’s updated monetary thresholds.
These are maximum amounts, not automatic fines for every violation. Actual penalties depend on the circumstances and enforcement.
Because fines can apply per violation, exposure can add up when an organization has multiple violations. The amounts are also subject to inflation adjustments.
A Fine Is Not the Only Cost of Noncompliance
Responding to complaints, investigating how data was collected, coordinating with vendors, and correcting broken processes can all take time and resources.
A documented deletion workflow helps your team respond consistently and spot gaps before they become larger problems.
What Does This Mean for Your Email Marketing Strategy?
Your email service provider (ESP) is only one part of your data management process. A contact record may also exist in your CRM or website database, and outside vendors may hold copies of the same information.
When someone submits a valid deletion request, your business needs to understand where their information lives and how to handle it in each location.
Begin by reviewing how contacts enter your database. Document the systems that store or receive that information, then establish a clear workflow for processing deletion requests.
Your process should also address how to prevent deleted records from being reimported. That may require coordination between your marketing team and the people responsible for your CRM, website, or external data providers.
Why Buying Email Lists Creates More Risk
The SB 923 update gives email marketers another reason to rethink purchased email lists.
Buying a list seems like a quick and easy way to reach more prospects. But those contacts often arrive with limited information about their origin, and create a practical challenge when someone asks you to delete their information.
A third-party provider’s claim that its list is compliant does not automatically satisfy your own legal obligations. Businesses covered by the CCPA must evaluate their responsibilities based on the data they hold and how they use it.
Purchased lists also create email marketing problems beyond privacy compliance. Contacts who never agreed to hear from your company may:
- Ignore your messages
- Unsubscribe from email marketing
- Report messages as spam
This can damage your sender reputation and make it harder to connect with those who genuinely want to hear from you.

Get Your Email Marketing Ready For 2027
California’s SB 923 expands the right to delete and makes data management an even more important part of email marketing. Businesses covered by the CCPA should use the time before January 1, 2027, to review their data sources, deletion procedures, and privacy request channels.
You do not need to rebuild your entire marketing program to make progress. Start by understanding where your contact information comes from and how it moves between systems.
And when it comes to growing your audience, focus on people who want to hear from you!
A permission-based email list is easier to manage, more valuable to your marketing efforts, and better for building lasting customer relationships.
CCPA Email Marketing: Your 2027 Guide
Download your free guide for email marketers on complying with SB 923.
Need help with your CCPA email marketing strategy? Tower can help.
By Danae